This past week, I've been avoiding a thorough review of my goals as I had a sneaky suspicion that I had failed at a number of them. That seemed debilitating and counter-productive. But as I forced myself to start writing this post, I began to realize just how much I had accomplished and more importantly, I came to realize that most of the failed goals floundered because I had not stayed true to myself. In the end, I had a major revelation. By confronting my anxiety, I destroyed it.
Last January, I had 3 major goals that were in part contingent on a number of factors. One of course was the pending job candidacy with ECU. As to those three goals, all were accomplished.
After our move to North Carolina, I re-wrote my year end goals (why? I'm not quite sure.) A number of those goals I did not accomplish. It left me wondering why not. Had I lost my mo-jo? Were the goals unrealistic? Was I not motivated to accomplish them? The truth is mostly the latter in part because I have been misleading myself away from my central purpose in life (CPL).
After numerous talks with some friends of mine, I have been re-conceptualizing the direction of my career to integrate my research, teaching, consulting, service, blog writing, and potential business ventures. Until just about 30 minutes ago, I had been considering two different directions, each of which seemed plausible for establishing that integration. I thought that by focusing on one of those two directions, I could stay true to my CPL. I was wrong! My original CPL already established the direction - to teach others how to make better decisions, specifically in designing,
building, maintaining, and using information systems. Today, I see no reason to pick one of the two different directions. The goals I was failing were all connected with choosing between these two directions. I need to web development knowledge in order to make better decisions. I need philosophic knowledge in order to make better decision. I need to understand how habits, information technologies, values, analysis and design techniques, epistemology, rationality, psychology, and productiveness can impact decision making. In short, my CPL already integrates these two passions of mine. Instead of picking one, I just need to remind myself of my ultimate passion - helping others to make better decisions. The rest follows.
So why did I fail at these goals? They failed because they met a mental block. Although crafted with my best intentions, I couldn't find the motivation to pursue them with the passion they deserved. Something just didn't seem right, although I couldn't put my finger on exactly what. The cognitive dissonance I experienced (and hence my failure to act on a number of projects/goals) stemmed from my mismatch between the reality of my CPL and the inappropriate goals I was setting. Contradictions cannot exist. My subconscious identified the contradiction first. It wasn't until today that my consciousness caught up.
So how to move forward? Rather than being frustrated with myself for not accomplishing my goals or falling behind in projects, I need to review all my projects and decide which ones will help me accomplish my CPL best and cut the rest. And that is my very next project!
Professor, father, husband, and lover of life. In this blog, I share my thoughts on my central purpose in life: to teach others how to make better decisions, specifically in designing, building, maintaining, and using information systems. I review books, explain scientific research, discuss philosophy, talk about education, and share my own experiences on how to make the best decisions for living a happy successful life.
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts
1.04.2012
10.28.2011
Confirmation bias
Recently, I read an article about confirmation bias that made me realize that this is major impediment to being productive. So, what is confirmation bias? According to Science Daily, confirmation bias is "a type of cognitive bias and represents an error of inductive inference toward confirmation of the hypothesis under study." Wikipedia lists some of the traits of confirmation bias to be:
There are two times confirmation bias can be observed, when you first develop an idea and when you are presented with new evidence that contradicts one of your existing ideas. If confirmation bias can be avoided in the former, the easier it will be managed in the latter. However, many people, myself included, have adopted ideas without fully evaluating all the evidence for and against when initially presented to them. Young kids are particularly susceptible. This may require re-evaluation of ideas that were once closely held. I have done this before when I reevaluated my belief in God and my interaction with The Objectivist Center, both of which led me to reject my earlier decisions based on new evidence.
2. Internal validity looks at the internal logic of an argument. Ask yourself if the evidence presented shows only part of the picture. Ask yourself if you have fully considered ALL of the evidence. Ask yourself if the conclusions are as solid as claimed. It may help to break up the argument into all of its component parts and verify that evidence supports each part. In short, play "devil's advocate" to establish internal validity.
3. External validity verifies an idea is consistent with the wider context of one's knowledge base. Ask yourself if this conclusion is true, what does it mean for other ideas. Ask yourself honestly what the evidence means for my life. The conclusion from the evidence should integrate with knowledge you already have without contradictions. If it doesn't, either something is wrong with your new conclusion or something is wrong with your existing ideas.
- Interpretation - When giving evidence both for and against your belief, the bias tends to focus only on the evidence for your belief and ignore evidence against your belief
- Search for information - You seek evidence from someone you know agrees with you and do not seek evidence from those that disagree with you.
- Memory - you tend to remember evidence that supports your argument and forget evidence that contradicts your position
There are two times confirmation bias can be observed, when you first develop an idea and when you are presented with new evidence that contradicts one of your existing ideas. If confirmation bias can be avoided in the former, the easier it will be managed in the latter. However, many people, myself included, have adopted ideas without fully evaluating all the evidence for and against when initially presented to them. Young kids are particularly susceptible. This may require re-evaluation of ideas that were once closely held. I have done this before when I reevaluated my belief in God and my interaction with The Objectivist Center, both of which led me to reject my earlier decisions based on new evidence.
Fortunately, there is a way to avoid confirmation bias - scientific inductive reasoning. Two principle techniques to scientific reasoning are establishing reliability and validity. Validity can be further sub-divided into both internal and external validity. So how can these be employed to avoid confirmation bias?
1. For evidence to be reliable, new evidence should confirm older evidence. If it contradicts it, chances are something fishy is going on or evidence is not being placed within its appropriate context. Seek evidence from multiple, disparate sources, particularly in emotionally driven complex issues. In highly controversial issues, its especially important to gather evidence from sources, both pro and con, and place that evidence within their proper context.2. Internal validity looks at the internal logic of an argument. Ask yourself if the evidence presented shows only part of the picture. Ask yourself if you have fully considered ALL of the evidence. Ask yourself if the conclusions are as solid as claimed. It may help to break up the argument into all of its component parts and verify that evidence supports each part. In short, play "devil's advocate" to establish internal validity.
3. External validity verifies an idea is consistent with the wider context of one's knowledge base. Ask yourself if this conclusion is true, what does it mean for other ideas. Ask yourself honestly what the evidence means for my life. The conclusion from the evidence should integrate with knowledge you already have without contradictions. If it doesn't, either something is wrong with your new conclusion or something is wrong with your existing ideas.
By employing these methods consistently, you can avoid confirmation bias. Take a step back from the emotional charged idea and be objective. If you do this, you have a good chance at avoiding confirmation bias and achieving objectivity in your thoughts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)